Mumble or Skype?

We use Skype a lot at Industrial Logic. But we also use VNC, and if the person running the VNC server has a low upstream bandwidth, the voice quality is unusable. We thought we might give Mumble/Murmur a try.

As it happens, I have done a bunch of research on VoIP technologies and speech codecs, so when I saw that Mumble uses Speex, I knew that it is on the right footing.

Two thing need to happen in order to get to the point where we can do some tests. The first is to set up the server. The Windows download of mumble includes murmur, and there are RPMs and static builds of murmur for Linux-based systems. As it happens, MacPorts has a murmur install, so on MacOS it's a simple matter of

port install murmur

Configuring the server — something I have yet to try — appears to be documented, but the proof is in the pudding.

Just for giggles, I fired up mumble in an attempt to connect to a public server. It seems that much of the goodness of mumble comes from it being configured correctly. In particular, it needs to be trained so that the background noise-filtering works correctly.

I have not reached on conclusion on whether mumble can replace skype for my bandwidth-challenged brethren. If I get 'round to installing murmur, we can give it a try.

Labels: macos, voip

0 comments